First storm watch · 32 winter products rated · prices re-checked weekly through January

Winter boots

Insulated boots for shovelling, the commute and the sledding hill, rated for the cold they actually handle.

Our winter boots picks

3 picked, not scored

Picked for the job, the price and what owners report after a winter. These are not put through the five-factor rubric the machines get; every pick still says when to walk past.

Best for walking

Columbia Bugaboot III Boot

The winter boot that walks like a hiking boot: 200 g of insulation, a waterproof Omni-Tech membrane and a lugged sole that grips, for the commute and the dog, not the drift.

200 G $130 MSRP · Amazon price not shown Check price on Amazon →
Best value

Kamik Nation Plus Winter Boot

A seam-sealed suede pac boot with a removable 145 g liner rated to minus 40, Canadian-made, for the price of a pair of gloves from the brand above it.

11 IN · 3.6 LB · 1 YEAR $129.99 MSRP · Amazon price not shown Check price on Amazon →
Best for slush

Muck Boot Arctic Sport Tall

A 16 in rubber boot over 5 mm neoprene, fully waterproof and rated from minus 40 to 40 F: the boot for the slush, the barn and the snow blower, pulled on without laces.

5 MM · 16 IN · 2.5 LB $175 MSRP · Amazon price not shown Check price on Amazon →