Ice dams: the roof rake, the heat cable, and the attic fix that ends them
Icicles at the eave are the symptom. Here is how to pull the snow off from the ground, keep a channel open where you cannot, and fix the house so you stop doing either.
An ice dam starts in the attic, not on the roof. Heat leaking up from the house melts the snow from underneath; the water runs down to the eave, which hangs out past the warm wall and stays cold, and refreezes there into a ridge. The ridge grows with every melt cycle until water pools behind it and backs up under the shingles, and the first sign inside is a brown stain at the top of an outside wall. Icicles along the eave are the outside sign. There are three defenses: take the snow off the eave before it melts, keep a channel open through the ice where you cannot, and stop the heat leak, which is the only one that ends it.
The roof rake is the first defense and it works from the ground. After any storm over about six inches, pull the first three to four feet of snow off the eave, which is the part that freezes; the snow higher up can stay. Rake from the ground, never from a ladder, stand to the side of where the slab will land, and look up for the power line that feeds the house before the first pull. Do not scrape to the shingle: leave an inch, because a rake edge takes the granules off and the roof ages a decade in an afternoon. On a metal roof, the whole slab can let go at once; stay out of the fall zone entirely.
The plain rake done right is the Avalanche SnowRake Deluxe 20. A 24 in poly head rides on built-in wheels so the edge never touches the shingles, five aluminum sections snap together to a 20 ft reach, and it is rated for shingles, shake, tile, metal and solar panels. It pulls snow down a strip at a time, which is slower than the slide-type tool below but works on crusted and refrozen snow where the slide stalls. At the full 20 ft the handle flexes and owners drop the head onto the snow to get a bite, and the bare aluminum leaves gray on gloves. A wall bracket comes in the box. Amazon lists it as currently unavailable, so it has no link on this page until it returns.
The Avalanche 500 is a different idea. Wheels ride the shingles while a 17 in by 12 ft plastic slide slips under the snow, and the snow lets go and rides the slide to the ground in sheets, with no pulling. On a day of fresh snow it clears an eave in a fraction of the time a rake takes. Its limits are real: it does nothing on crusted or refrozen snow, the slide flaps and can tear in wind, the four-section fiberglass pole reaches about 16 ft, and the 500 model is for asphalt shingles only; the 750 model has the bigger wheels for metal, shake, tile and solar. It costs about two plain rakes.
Which one: a single-story house in snow country with regular storms wants the Avalanche 500 and the habit of using it the day the snow falls. A house that sees a few storms a winter, a metal or tile roof, or snow that has already crusted wants the SnowRake. A two-story eave sits 18 to 20 ft up, which is past the 500 and at the flexing end of the SnowRake; for that house the rake handles the porch and garage roofs, and the attic fix below is the answer for the rest.
Heat cable is the second defense, for the eave you cannot reach or the valley that dams every year. The Frost King RC60 is 60 ft of constant-wattage cable, 5 W per foot, 300 W in all, pre-assembled with a plug, shingle clips and spacers. It zigzags along the eave in a W pattern and runs down the downspout, and it does one thing: keeps a channel open so meltwater gets off the roof instead of pooling behind the ice. It does not clear snow and it does not stop the dam from forming. Sizing is where people go wrong: Frost King's own rule is 80 ft of cable for every 20 ft of roof edge including the downspout, so the 60 ft kit covers about 15 ft of eave. Measure before you buy, and expect to want the clip pack, because the kit ships short.
Three rules for the cable. It is for shingle roofs; Frost King does not rate it for metal. It needs an outdoor outlet on a ground-fault circuit, plugged in before the snow and unplugged once the weather stays above freezing; a plug-in thermostat, sold separately, does that switching for you and is worth having, because 300 W around the clock is about seven kilowatt-hours a day on the meter. And install it in the fall on a day above 40 F, because the clips tuck under shingles that crack when they are cold.
Melt tablets are the third option and the one we do not link. Calcium chloride pucks tossed onto the dam from the ground do melt a channel through it in a few hours, which is useful the week the ceiling starts to drip. They also corrode the gutter, the flashing and the nails, stain light siding and salt the beds below the downspout, and the round pucks mostly roll off a pitched roof. If you use the chemistry, use the old trick instead: fill a leg of nylon stocking with calcium chloride pellets and lay it across the dam so it hangs over the edge; it stays put and melts a channel. Never rock salt on a roof.
For an active leak: a box fan in the attic aimed at the underside of the wet spot refreezes the water and stops the drip within an hour, which buys time. A roofing company with a steam machine takes the dam off without harming the shingles; a hatchet, a hammer or a pressure washer does not. And no one goes up on an iced roof.
The permanent fix is in the attic, and it is summer work. Air-seal the ceiling first: the gaps around can lights, the bath fan, the plumbing stack, the top of the interior walls and the attic hatch are where the warm air leaves. Then insulate to at least R-49, which is the floor for snow country and R-60 under the newest code, and make sure every bath and dryer fan vents outside rather than into the attic. Keep the soffit vents open past the insulation so cold air moves under the roof deck. A house with a cold roof wears its snow evenly all winter and grows no icicles; that is the test, and it is the whole point.
The season in one list: gutters cleaned in November so the channel has somewhere to drain; cable installed and tested on a warm fall day; the rake hung by the garage door and used after every storm over six inches; the attic sealed and insulated the next summer, after which the rake mostly stays on its bracket.