First storm watch · 32 winter products rated · prices re-checked weekly through January

Gloves and mittensBest all-round glove

Carhartt · A511 (GL0511)

Carhartt Waterproof Insulated Knit Cuff Glove

The glove in every hardware store for a reason: a waterproof insert, a grippy palm and a snug knit cuff for the price of lunch, warm for the shovel and the dog walk and nothing longer.

Amazon link · we earn a commission if you buy · $34.99 MSRP · Amazon price not shown · verified Oct 23, 2026

Why we picked it

The glove in every hardware store for a reason: a waterproof insert, a grippy palm and a snug knit cuff for the price of lunch, warm for the shovel and the dog walk and nothing longer.

Known issue · Warm for an hour of shoveling and not much longer: owners report fingers going cold on a long walk even above freezing, and most say to order a size upZappos owner reviews

Built from 3 sources: 2 owner threads, 1 spec page.

Take it home if

  • Waterproof insert and a FastDry lining that wicks sweat
  • Knit cuff seals under a jacket sleeve; grip palm holds a shovel
  • Thirty-seven thousand reviews and a maker guarantee behind it

Walk past if

  • Warm for an hour, not an afternoon; below 20 F the fingers go first
  • Runs small; order a size up
  • The grip coating wears off the fingertips within a season of hard use

Spec sheet

Manufacturer ratings, not our measurements.

Shell
Polyester and softshell with a synthetic grip palm
Waterproofing
Waterproof insert
Lining
FastDry wicking lining over synthetic insulation
Cuff
Knit cuff
Guarantee
Carhartt repair, replace or credit

Alternatives

The nearest in its class, then the nearest rival among gloves and mittens.

Best leather glove

Kinco 901 Lined Pigskin Ski Glove

The lift-operator's glove: full-grain pigskin, a thermal lining, double-stitched seams and a packet of wax in the box, because it leaks until you wax it and then lasts for years.

$53.99 MSRP · Amazon price not shown Check price on Amazon →